After Arroyo, What Then???

[top to bottom: Rep Luz Illagan, Gabriella Women’s Party; Rep Ocampo, Bayan Muna; Rep. Beltran, Anakpawis]

* * *

by alex

“’But what shall we substitute in it’s place,’ you say? What? A ferocious animal has sucked the blood of my relatives. I tell you to rid yourselves of this beast, and you ask me what you shall put in it’s place?”—Voltaire

CBT’s “People Power,” the recent Toronto visit of three progressive Philippine congresspersons, and the continuing bad news coming from the homeland has a lot in the Filipino community and others wondering about what to do about politics in the Phils.

I think a lot of us accept that there is a lot wrong with the Philippine gov:

Over 900 have been killed for political reasons, and over 200,000 affected by military operations during Arroyo’s term in office [former according to Karapatan, latter by UNICEF, both supported by the UN Special Rapporteur Report]

It’s considered the most corrupt in Southeast Asia—a spot once held by Indonesia [according to ‘Political and Economic Risk Consultancy’]

Between 2000-05 it was the most dangerous place in the world for a journalist to work, in 2006 it was number two (Iraq took over #1), and now it’s number three [according to Reporters Without Borders]. This number only went down (with the political killings) because of the international pressure which led to the UN Special Rapporteur visit–see link below.

Despite a growing GDP (due to privatization of public assests, and increased foreign investment in commodities like gold), real economic growth (ie. more money for the common people) is worse than nonexistent, it’s shrinking.

Because of the above there has been a growing voice to remove the current Arroyo administration from power. The problem is: What happens next???

That question has been a major hurdle for a lot of Filipinos in-country and abroad. And though I understand it, I am reminded of the Voltaire quote I led off this piece with.

Well, despite my old obsession with Voltaire, I think this question does deserve an answer. Rep. Satur Ocampo, the former Marcos-era political prisoner who was imprisoned longer than anyone else, spoke at U of T last week and gave an answer.

He told the crowded room that there were three options on the table (should the Arroyo regime be ousted):

1) Constitutional Succession

2) A Snap Election

3) A Temporary Civilian Transition Government

With the first option, GMA would be forced to step down and the vice president would become president. The problem here is that Noli de Castro is a GMA team player. The former news broadcaster is not expected to be any different from Gloria.

With the second option, the problem is much like the first. An election would only pit political elites in an electoral contest with no likelihood for much change as the interests of the elite do would be to keep the status quo.

And the final option, and the one that these three congresspersons seem to subscribe to, is that after the ouster of GMA that the constitution of the Philippines be renewed by a Civilian Transition Government made up of all the political groups in the government, with the participation of established social justice groups. A timeline would be set for recreating the system that creates and governs government, and with that the Philippines could begin anew.

This third option is not without problems:

Is this kind of a political “reset” button really possible?

How would the composition of this temp transition gov be decided—and by whom?

And would the powers that be in the Phils and abroad really allow this to happen?

What do you think? I have struggled with this question myself and I would love to hear what others think…

* * *


Karapatan 2007 Human Rights Report:

UN Special Rapporteur Philip Alston confirmed much of this in his 2007 report and clearly points the finger at the government. To download his final report please visit:


~ by alexfelipe on April 19, 2008.

4 Responses to “After Arroyo, What Then???”

  1. Among the choices, I personally prefer the third. To the question of is it possible, I would say yes. Definitely in this scenario Arroyo would be removed in an extra constitutional way and masses have already spoken. The point is no one would want to let opportunist run the show again just like the last time. Tothe question of who gets to choose who compose the council, it should be coming from the different sectors… It won’t be a one man game to appoint who gets sit or not. And finally, will this be allowed by the imperialist powers that be? Of course if it would lead to losing their interest to the country, they won’t allow it but still we have what we call sovereignty and at the end of it all THE PEOPLE ARE STILL DECISIVE. 🙂

    Just my Two cents and by the way nice photos.

  2. … its like razing it to the ground in order to build it again.

    If GMA gets taken down and then a CTG gets put up even WITH the social justice groups, that’s an even MORE dramatic movie plot than EDSA1/People Power was!

    Geez, we love drama.

    I like the idea of #3 too, but forgive me for being a cynic: the Philippines is so neck-deep in layers of corruption that I’m skeptical even a CTG can be put up without SOMETHING fishy going on.

    To throw another twist in the plot, I’ve also heard the following suggestion that something like #3 could be done after GMA’s term is over and without extra-judicial measures.

    That’s not my viewpoint but I found it interesting and it made me wonder.

  3. Yup it’s a tough one, and I agree that it will be a BIG hurdle to do anything in the Phils without something “fishy” going on.

    But over and over I hear from Fil expats that no matter what happens there will be corruption: even if everything was to be scrapped and restarted nothing would change. While I can understand the doubt I cannot help thinking that such though helps no one—no, it helps only the status quo.

    We have to try to succeed. And failure is much more noble than simply giving up.

  4. And have you guys heard that Ka Satur is again being re-charged with murder charges? He found out while still in Canada, and since returning he has been in fear for his life. He claims his house is being staked out by motorcycle riding goons (the usual M.O. of the military gunmen that have taken the most lives).

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: